Skip to main content
  • About
    • CoBiVa Description
    • Research Team
    • login
  • Resources
    • Researchers
    • Teachers
    • Community
    • Links to Other Sociolinguistic Corpora
  • Research & News
    • Cobiva News
    • CoBiVa Research
    • Press Releases
  • Cite the Corpus
  • Español
DIRECTORY
MAPS
MYUTRGV
UTRGV
The University of Texas
Rio Grande Valley
DIRECTORY
MAPS
MYUTRGV
News
GIVE
Open Search Menu
Menu
utrgv logo
Corpus Bilingüe del Valle CoBiVa
Department of Writing and Language Studies
  • About  Square placeholder image 300px
    About
    • CoBiVa Description
    • Research Team
    • Login
  • Resources Square placeholder image 300px
    Resources
    • Researchers
    • Teachers
    • Community
    • Links to Other Sociolinguistic Corpora
  • Research & News Square placeholder image 300px
    Research & News
    • Cobiva News
    • CoBiVa Research
    • Press Releases
  • Cite the Corpus
  • Español
screenshot of one example of the transcript methods

Testing Technologically Aided

Hexagons
  • Home
  • Research & News
  • Cobiva News
  • News Archive
  • Testing Technologically Aided
Español

Testing Technologically Aided Transcription- Training & Methods

screenshot of one example of the transcript methods

During July, the PI and co-PIs on the project, funded by the National Endowment for the Humanities, met often to determine the design and organization of the trials for the transcription methods.

The PI and co-PIs worked with six (6) research assistants (RAs). The three (3) students from the University of Arizona (UA) were all PhD students, while the three (3) students from the University of Texas Rio Grande Valley (UTRGV) included: two students who completed their bachelor's degrees and were starting their MA in the Fall as well as one student who had just finished their MA at UTRGV.

The team decided to test the transcription methods with four (4) two-minute audio files - two (2) from the Corpus Bilingüe del Valle (CoBiVa, UTRGV corpus) and two (2) from the Corpus del Español en Arizona (CESA, UA corpus). These audio files were selected to demonstrate a variety of different features within the corpora, including background noise, higher speed, and slower more enunciated speech. (An additional file was used for the short 30 second test.)

The research team organized the transcription testing trials in Teams. The trials were organized into six (6) modules, one for training and focus groups, one for each of the four audio files, and one for the final survey and focus groups. (See below.)

 

The trials were organized into three (3) weeks with three synchronous meetings via Zoom. One after the training module, another after the Interview 1 module, and a final one at the end of the project. The research team members met with RAs as needed to review/problem solve issues that arose and provide additional instruction.

For the first training module, the research team created a series of instructional videos including:

  • 3 overall instructional videos on the project and the transcription protocol
  • 1 instructional video on ExpressScribe
  • 2 instructional videos on SpeechNotes
  • 4 instructional videos for Stream

As a part of the training module, the RAs completed a short 30 second audio file transcription using the three methods. The research team provided feedback for each RA, and then the team met to discuss.

During each of the four interview transcription modules, the RAs completed the transcription using each of the three methods. They carefully recorded the time required for each of the methods, and after each method, they filled out a survey on ease of use, speed, and general experience/process. The order of the methods was different for each module/interview audio. (See details below.)

Schedule for Testing of Transcription Methods

Revised on August 5, 2020

Office hours and individual meetings are available by appointment.

https://utrgv.zoom.us/j/6074480681

Schedule of tasks and due dates for transcription method testing
Week Tasks Due Date
Week 1 Optional Office Hours Wednesday, July 29 – Thursday, July 30
4:00–5:00 p.m. Texas time
2:00–3:00 p.m. Arizona time
Week 1 Module 1 – Tasks Due
  1. Submit Bilingual Language Profile.
  2. Complete Transcription Experience Survey.
  3. View ExpressScribe video training and submit ExpressScribe practice transcript.
  4. View SpeechNotes video training and submit SpeechNotes practice transcript.
  5. View Stream video training and submit Stream practice transcript.
Thursday, July 30, by 11:59 p.m.
Week 1 Intro Meeting Friday, July 31
4:00–4:30 p.m. Texas time
2:00–2:30 p.m. Arizona time
Week 2 Module 2 – Tasks Due
  1. Complete the Interview 1 ExpressScribe transcript. Submit the transcript and survey, and download, record, and submit the Excel Time Tracking Sheet.
  2. Complete the Interview 1 SpeechNotes transcript. Submit the transcript and survey, and download, record, and upload the Excel Time Tracking Sheet.
  3. Complete the Interview 1 Stream transcript. Submit the transcript and survey, and download, record, and upload the Excel Time Tracking Sheet.
Tuesday, August 4, by 11:59 p.m.
Week 2 Week 2 Meeting Wednesday, August 5
4:00–4:30 p.m. Texas time
2:00–2:30 p.m. Arizona time
Week 2 Module 3 – Tasks Due
  1. Complete the Interview 2 SpeechNotes transcript. Submit the transcript, survey, and TimeSheet.
  2. Complete the Interview 2 Stream transcript. Submit the transcript, survey, and TimeSheet.
  3. Complete the Interview 2 ExpressScribe transcript. Submit the transcript, survey, and TimeSheet.
Friday, August 7, by 11:59 p.m.
Week 3 Module 4 – Tasks Due
  1. Complete the Interview 3 Stream transcript. Submit the transcript, survey, and Excel Time Tracking Sheet.
  2. Complete the Interview 3 ExpressScribe transcript. Submit the transcript, survey, and Excel Time Tracking Sheet.
  3. Complete the Interview 3 SpeechNotes transcript. Submit the transcript, survey, and Excel Time Tracking Sheet.
Monday, August 10, by 11:59 p.m.
Week 3 Module 5 – Tasks Due
  1. Complete the Interview 4 ExpressScribe transcript. Submit the transcript, survey, and TimeSheet.
  2. Complete the Interview 4 Stream transcript. Submit the transcript, survey, and TimeSheet.
  3. Complete the Interview 4 SpeechNotes transcript. Submit the transcript, survey, and TimeSheet.
  4. Complete the Final Survey.
Thursday, August 13, by 11:59 p.m.
Week 3 Final Meeting Friday, August 14
4:00–5:00 p.m. Texas time
2:00–3:00 p.m. Arizona time

 

The last module (Module 6 Final Survey and Focus Groups) provided an opportunity for students to complete a final survey comparing and explaining their experiences with the three transcription methods in more detail. The focus group allowed students to discuss their experiences with one another, and it also allowed the researchers to ask follow up questions based on the RAs' surveys and their observations throughout the process.

Check out upcoming blog posts for our preliminary analysis of the transcription method trials.

UTRGV Trademark logo
  • CARES, CRRSAA and ARP Reporting
  • Site Policies
  • Required Links
  • Accreditation Statement
  • Fraud Reporting
  • Senate Bill 18
  • Clery Act Reports
  • Web Accessibility
  • Mental Health Resources
  • Sexual Misconduct Policy
  • Reporting Sexual Misconduct
  • Contact UTRGV
  • 1-844-ATUTRGV
  • Facebook
  • X Twitter
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Academics
  • Admissions
  • Cost and Financial Aid
  • Student Life
  • Search Programs
  • First-Year Students
  • Transfer
  • International Students
  • Graduate Students
  • Current Students
  • Faculty Resources
  • Staff Resources
  • UTRGV Careers
  • Visit Campus
  • Directory
The University of Texas Rio Grande Valley